Casey Key Real Estate

Casey Key Real Estate

Welcome to Casey Key, a stunning subdivision located in Sarasota County, Florida. This exclusive area spans the cities of Osprey and Nokomis, offering residents a unique and luxurious coastal living experience.

Casey Key is a hidden gem nestled along the Gulf of Mexico, renowned for its pristine beaches, lush tropical landscapes, and breathtaking sunsets. This idyllic location is a haven for those seeking tranquility and natural beauty, making it a highly desirable place to call home.

The subdivision of Casey Key is known for its prestigious waterfront properties, offering residents direct access to the sparkling blue waters of the Gulf. From grand estates to charming beach cottages, the real estate options here cater to a variety of tastes and lifestyles.

Aside from its picturesque shoreline, Casey Key is also home to a vibrant community with a range of amenities. The nearby cities of Osprey and Nokomis provide residents with convenient access to shopping centers, dining options, and recreational activities such as golfing, boating, and fishing.

Nature enthusiasts will appreciate the proximity to parks and nature preserves, including the Oscar Scherer State Park and the Myakka River State Park. These natural wonders offer endless opportunities for hiking, bird-watching, and exploring the unique flora and fauna of the region.

With its prime location, luxurious properties, and unparalleled natural beauty, Casey Key is truly a hidden paradise on Florida's Gulf Coast. Whether you're looking for a permanent residence or a vacation getaway, this subdivision offers the perfect blend of serenity and sophistication.

Newest Listings in Casey Key

$11,795,000
5 Beds 6.5 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34275 Zip Code
Welcome to this exquisite Casey Key custom built home ideally placed on the pristine sands of the Gulf of Mexico. This breathtaking property offers 90 feet of beachfront and sits on over three quarters of an acre with a picturesque gulf-front pool and a great South Key location providing easy access to the mainland. This solid built expansive home emits luxury and craftmanship in every detail and provides a place for everyone and everything expanding over 6,500 interior square feet and over 12,000 total square feet. Colorful and vibrant water views can be experienced from two gulf-facing primary suites with private balconies, private sitting areas and lavishly appointed baths, a two-story living room with floor-to-ceiling windows, a great room just off the gourmet kitchen and a private and elegantly appointed water view office. There are three additional en suite spacious bedrooms, all accessible by either the grand staircase or elevator and two full baths providing access to the saltwater pool and Jacuzzi on the expansive travertine pool deck. No aspect of luxury and convenience has been overlooked with a Lutron lighting system, fully automated ultra quiet solar fabric and room darkening window shades throughout the entire home, a technology and internet package that just has to be seen, easy-to-maintain marble floors, step, trey or coffered ceiling details in every room, gas-burning fireplace, Italian marble interior fountain, laundry room plus an additional main level laundry closet, and a kitchen with a wish list of professional appliances that will delight any chef. There is even a full butler’s pantry leading to an ideally sized and finished formal dining room with custom Venetian plaster walls giving it that extra wow factor. The exterior provides private and generous entertaining space leading to a beautifully crafted dune walk-over for quick access to your beach, and a mosquito-repellent system surrounding the perimeter of the home. Ease of entry and exit with a circular paver driveway leading to a porte-cochere, and side entry three-car garage with extra storage room for kayaks and canoes to use at the deeded bay access that comes with this home. For peace of mind and comfort, this home was built to hurricane codes in 2008 with all impact windows and doors, a full reverse osmosis water system, industrial long-lasting gas generator, 1,000-gallon propane tank and an aerobic septic tank system with a newer drain field. Finishing off the exquisite home are areas where movies can be watched, homework can be completed, sleepovers can be hosted, and a good workout can be had. A large walkable beach to the north and south, close to great restaurants, a marina with boat storage close by, and just a short drive to downtown Sarasota makes this beachfront home on the secluded and unrivaled tropical haven of Casey Key the unique property you have been waiting for.

507 Casey Key Road, Nokomis

$4,400,000
4 Beds 3.5 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34229 Zip Code
Welcome to your very own Gulf front beach home located on one of the most captivating, serene and exclusive barrier islands on Florida's west coast. This custom 4 bedroom 3.5 bathroom mid-century modern luxury property is directly on the Gulf with absolutely stunning unobstructed views and your very own private beach. Relax in the sun on the patio or take in the gorgeous sunsets from almost every room. You'll love the open living area with large ceramic tiles throughout, vaulted exposed beam ceilings, fireplace and dining room that adjoins the beautiful kitchen. The kitchen features lovely quartz countertops and stainless appliances. The beach carries indoors with the charm and character of local beach shells crushed and floated in natural cement to create textured walls that brings the outside indoors. Listen to the waves as you fall asleep in your upper level primary suite with gorgeous water views and maximum privacy for both owners and guests. The peaceful bedrooms also include a second primary suite on the first floor. The gated entry onto the property brings you into complete privacy and seclusion with lush landscaping and large shade trees. Enjoy sitting in the shade of the magnificent live oak around the fountain on your over 1/2 acre lot. Take a walk or drive your golf cart to the famous Casey Key Fish House and Deep Lagoon upscale restaurant and marina, only a half mile to the supermarket, and a quick drive to all of the wonderful shops and restaurants Sarasota and Venice has to offer. Easy access to the mainland and I-75 via the iconic Blackburn Point Bridge nearby.

5 N Casey Key Road, Osprey

$8,500,000
4 Beds 4.5 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34275 Zip Code
Nestled along the pristine shores of Casey Key, this luxurious residence optimizes coastal living at its finest. Boasting breathtaking panoramic views of the Gulf of Mexico, this 4-bedroom, 4.5-bathroom plus pool room with full bath, home is a masterpiece of architectural design and opulent comfort. Upon entering, guests are greeted by an elegant foyer leading to a spacious living area adorned with floor-to-ceiling windows and balcony, allowing natural light to cascade throughout the space and offering uninterrupted vistas of the turquoise waters beyond. The open-concept layout seamlessly connects the living room, dining area, and gourmet kitchen, creating an ideal setting for entertaining or simply enjoying tranquil evenings with loved ones. The kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring top-of-the-line appliances, custom cabinetry, and a center island with bar seating. Adjacent to the kitchen is an inclusive dining area, perfect for enjoying morning coffee while soaking in the breathtaking views or entertaining guests for dinner parties. For added convenience, an elevator provides easy access to all levels of the home, ensuring accessibility for residents and guests alike. The master suite, located on the main floor, is a sanctuary unto itself, complete with a spa-like bathroom featuring a walk-in shower, dual vanities, and a walk-in closet. With floor to ceiling picture windows, waking to the serene views is easy with remote shades for optimal relaxation and resting. On the second floor, you'll discover three additional bedroom suites, each providing serene havens. One suite could be a second master suite with soaking tub, dual vanity, and walk-in shower and closet that provide a private escape of expansive coastal views. Adjacent to these bedrooms, a family room awaits, ideal for hosting gatherings or unwinding in comfort. Step out onto the expansive balcony and immerse yourself in the soothing melody of waves crashing against the shore, enhancing the atmosphere of relaxation and tranquility. The expansive outdoor living space is an entertainer's paradise, featuring a sparkling salt water heated pool and spa overlooking the Gulf, a spacious deck for sunbathing, and a putting green for golf enthusiasts. Outdoor kitchen by the pool area and on the main level makes it easy to entertain in both areas watching the award winning sunsets of Casey Key. The pool room with dishwasher, sink, ice maker, and refrigerator plus full bath makes after pool or beach fun easily cleaned up and not tracked through the main home. Full feature sheet attached as the upgrades are endless! With its unparalleled location, luxurious amenities, and unparalleled views, this Casey Key residence offers a rare opportunity to experience coastal living at its absolute finest. Whether as a full-time residence or a vacation retreat, this magnificent home is sure to exceed even the most discerning buyer's expectations.

3801 Casey Key Road, Nokomis

$2,140,000
5 Beds 3 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34275 Zip Code
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. IT'S ALWAYS ALL ABOUT THE LOCATION! Casey Key is a very private narrow barrier island located just North of Venice FL and South of Siesta Key; it separates the intracostal waterway and the Gulf of Mexico. The Key is home to some of the most luxurious waterfront Estates and Mansions in the Sarasota area. This large ½ acre Bayfront lot is peacefully set back from any traffic on Casey Key Road. The dock is on the North side of the property on a canal protected from wind and waves. From the living room or the Bay-side deck, views of the intracoastal waterway and its many traveling boats and yachts are stunning. Take a short 100 yard stroll down your deeded beach easement, to the pristine sands of the Gulf of Mexico. The beach is very private, ideal for swimming, snorkeling, sunbathing, shark tooth hunting, or just viewing the beautiful sunsets. The main floor houses 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths, the kitchen and the dining room. The first floor has one full bath and 3 rooms that can be used as bedrooms, rec room, den, etc. Other amenities include swimming pool, shuffle board court, elevator, and two single car garages. A new roof was installed in 2019. Live in the house "as is" or convert it to the home of your dreams located in paradise. Note: Some images have been virtually staged to better showcase the true potential of rooms and spaces in the home.

1210 Casey Key Road, Nokomis

$10,500,000
6 Beds 7.5 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34229 Zip Code
Along the beaches of Casey Key, a private gated road leads to the exclusive northern end of this coveted barrier island. Sited on nearly 2.5 acres and 150 feet of private beach front, lies a spectacular estate home that has been shared and enjoyed by one family for generations. Designed by renowned architect Timothy Siebert, the property was thoughtfully planned as a gathering place. Wrapped around the inner courtyard, 6 en-suite bedrooms, 7 and 1 half baths, provide guests with access to a resurfaced pool, spa and tennis court and their own private retreats. High ceilings throughout emphasize the grandeur of the spacious rooms. The large kitchen and formal dining rooms are ideal for preparing and serving every culinary delight. Stepping across the expansive front lawn, enhanced with exotic palms, a private boardwalk leads to the powdered sugar quartz sand beach. One can walk for miles with turquoise blue water along the Gulf of Mexico or enjoy a place to rest on the shore with a fabulous book. With no public beach access for miles, guests are pleasantly surprised how quiet and seemingly uninhabited Casey Key remains. Designated as a conservation district by the State of Florida, building is reserved for single family homes. There are no high rises or condominiums permitted and the reputation for its natural beauty and elegance will be retained for generations to come. Private and commercial air travel in nearby Venice and Sarasota are so convenient. Shopping, golf and restaurants are all easily accessible making this destination nearly too good to be true. One of the Sarasota areas most exclusive addresses, North Casey Key will not disappoint.

1544 N Casey Key Road, Osprey

$11,900,000
5 Beds 6 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34275 Zip Code
$600,000. Price Reduction! When you come up the steps and enter the Courtyard Gates the Black Lagoon Pool & Spa are to your left and on your right is a Rock Wall Waterfall both created by Lucas Lagoons. Straight ahead are the steps to the large Wood & Glass Custom Hurricane Entry Doors. Looking through to the large Entry & Great Room with wet bar & the wall of glass & the Beautiful Colors of the Gulf of Mexico catch your attention. Upon entry the formal Dining room is to your left & then the Large Kitchen with Sub-Zero Freezer & separate Sub-Zero Refrigerator. There is a Custom Copper Hood over the Large Wolf Cook Top, there is also a Wolf Convection Oven, Microwave and Warming Draw a Mele Dishwasher & Fisher & Paykel Dishwasher Draws and a nice Walk-in Pantry. The custom cabinets are made by Das Holz Haus. The Island Granite is doubled & top piece has a Chiseled Edge & is the Palamino Pattern. The main sink is a Copper Farmhouse which coordinates with the Copper Hood. There is also a Vegetable Sink in the Large Wraparound Bar & Counter which is great for entertaining large parties. All with Spectacular Views of the Beach & Gulf of Mexico & with a Covered & Open Balcony Porch across the back of the Kitchen Eating Area and Great Room. Also on this level is the Office/Library and a Full Bath. The Loft area is the Family Room with Wet Bar & the 5th en suite Bedroom all of which easily closes off for a large private guest area. There is also the possibility of an In-Laws Suite. Upstairs you have your Primary Suite and Three other en suite Bedrooms two with Walkin Closets and Large Balconies. On the South side is a Large Open Balcony Deck for enjoying the sun and on the North is a covered Balcony which is shaded when you just want to relax watching & listening to the surf. The Large Primary Suite is Gulf Side with Covered Gulf Balconies. Also Gulf Front is the Large Primary Bath with Separate Whirlpool Tub and Large Multi Head Shower and a Bidet and Makeup Vanity. The Primary closet is a room in itself with all the Built-ins, an Island and even a Large Rotating Closet Carousel. The Home is being sold Furnished except a few personal items making it easy for you to move right in. There is also an Oversized Three Car Plus Golf Cart Garage with work area and Sink. The home was designed by Sarasota Architect George Merlin. There is a Five Stage (wheelchair assessable) Elevator to service all levels. The Lower Level is a bonus 2365 SQ/FT and is a non-conforming space used for storage and exercise also with wonderful views of the Beach and Gulf and access to Pool & Spa Deck. The property is also protected by a Massive Soil Cement Stairstep Revetment Wall that goes down twenty plus steps protecting several properties in both directions

2821 Casey Key Road, Nokomis

$2,999,900
3 Beds 3 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34275 Zip Code
Discover the epitome of waterfront living at this stunning Casey Key bayfront estate! Boasting 121 feet of prime intercoastal waterway frontage, this property is a paradise for boating and fishing enthusiasts. Your dream coastal lifestyle awaits you! Step into this magnificent home and be greeted by an inviting open concept layout that is sure to please. This is a true split plan home, with the master suite located on the south side and the guest suites on the north side. The panoramic views from the living room are nothing short of breathtaking, as you gaze out over the sparkling pool and the expansive bay beyond. Your furry friends are not forgotten – the yard has been thoughtfully fenced in, and an easement has been secured to ensure your privacy. The spacious living room provides ample space for entertaining and features a cozy fireplace for those occasional chilly Florida evenings. The rear of the house is adorned with walls of windows, offering unparalleled views for you to relax and enjoy. This home is bathed in natural light, with certain areas of the ceiling finished in wood to create a warm and inviting atmosphere. The open kitchen, overlooking the bay, is a chef's delight. The master bedroom is a sanctuary of its own, with a private sitting area and a full bath featuring a luxurious new soaking tub. Ample closet space and a new mini split system add to your comfort. Updates abound in this home, including a new air conditioning system throughout and mini splits in every bedroom. A new awning has been added by the pool, ensuring that you can enjoy outdoor living in style. The south side has a new fence leading to the bay, and the easement to the beach has been thoughtfully upgraded. The dock was completely redone just last year, promising countless exciting days on the water. For those seeking to savor the local culinary delights, you can take a leisurely walk or hop in your golf cart to reach the famous Casey Key Fish House and the upscale Deep Lagoon restaurant and marina. Need to stock up? You're conveniently close to the supermarket. A quick drive will take you to the myriad shops and restaurants in Sarasota and Venice, offering endless dining and shopping options. With easy access to the mainland and I-75 via the iconic Blackburn Point Bridge nearby, this Casey Key bayfront estate offers the ideal blend of serene coastal living and modern convenience. Don't miss the opportunity to call this stunning property your home – schedule your showing today and experience the unparalleled beauty and luxury for yourself!

2812 Casey Key Road, Nokomis

$3,795,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34275 Zip Code
Price Improvement! If you are looking for a slice of island paradise for your winter escape, or seeking incredible quality of life to enjoy year-round, this gem on the barrier island of Casey Key is unlike any other. A haven of tranquility, this special bayfront cottage, with lush landscaping, offers an incredible panorama overlooking the widest part of Blackburn Bay from every room. Sliding doors open to a coral-stone paver patio creating an indoor-outdoor living experience. Watch the dolphins and seabirds passing through daily. Relax and soak up the sun, or savor the endless views from the shade, while you unwind in the serenity of your own private retreat. A boater’s dream, this property has over 200 linear feet of superior quality brand new seawall and dock, providing convenient water access and breathtaking sunrises and sunset skies. Ultimate privacy with no neighboring homes on the adjacent bayfront parcels creates an exceptional setting, even for this island of many spectacular properties. The secluded enclave of Casey Key offers its own unique advantages due to restrictions allowing for only low-density residential development. The island itself is a paradise, providing easy access end-to-end by golf cart to numerous restaurants, shops, and a beautiful unspoiled beach with azure waters and amazing Florida sunsets. The island is just 15 miles from downtown Sarasota’s renowned arts and entertainment and very convenient to the airport. Just minutes away to the south, by car or boat, you can access Venice Island’s charming downtown with its shops and dining. Don't miss the opportunity to make this coastal dream your reality.

2410 Casey Key Road, Nokomis

Start Your Search